Thehe point everything changed for John Lodge and his fellow musicians in the Moody Blues happened one night at the Fiesta club in Stockton. Lodge and Justin Hayward were new to the band, with Lodge handling bass and Hayward on lead guitar. They had been scheduled for a well-paid series of cabaret shows across northern England. The Moodies were playing a revue-style show, mixing R&B with comedy numbers, all while dressed in blue suits. They had scored a big hit a few years earlier with "Go Now," but by 1966, their style and music seemed outdated.
After the show, Hayward mentioned in a past interview, a man approached the backstage area to talk with the group. "Typically, people would say something like, 'Oh, you're great.' But he stated, 'I just thought I'd tell you, you're the worst fucking band I've seen in my life. You're rubbish. And somebody's got to tell you.'" Hayward and singer Ray Thomas were reduced to tears, and afterwards, as their vehicle headed back from the location, drummer Graeme Edge spoke up from the rear: "That guy's right. We're awful."
The next day, the Moodies pledged to abandon the suits, the routine, and the past, and reinvent themselves. In this process, they emerged as UK rock's least appreciated band: pioneers of a distinct sound, consistent chart-toppers across multiple decades in the United States, and Hall of Fame members who performed at prestige venues on each side of the Atlantic until their career ended in 2018 with a Vegas residency.
And John Lodge, who passed away at the age 82, was key to that lasting success, as bass player, singer, and composer. With Days of Future Passed in 1967, the Moody Blues didn't just embrace the new psychedelic fashions but integrated them and catapulted past them in one movement: a prior year, they had been a variety act, and now they were creating the elements that would form a new genre: progressive rock.
It's not as if the Moodies were particularly inclined to lengthy compositions with multiple time signatures. They wrote what were, at heart, catchy tunes, but enveloped them in beautiful orchestrations, with rich harmonies and detailed instrumentation (the signature sound in "Nights in White Satin," their "legacy" track, isn't the guitar: it's the flute). They grasped the possibilities of the recording studio in a way few of their contemporaries did. And in a band packed with talented composers, Lodge more than held his own.
"Ride My See-Saw," from 1968's "In Search of the Lost Chord," showcased Lodge's skills: you can hear the rhythm and blues band in the beat and Hayward's staccato guitar, but the singing are stacked so deeply the song becomes almost hymnal. It's very much of its time, but also completely fantastic – the sound of popular music evolving in the moment, in the studio. (There's a live version from 1969's that's electrifying: this group really could rock.)
Lodge had chosen to be a bass player because he loved keyboard players. As he stated in a 2023 interview: "When I was at school, there was a cafe right by my school with a branded jukebox. Every lunchtime, I used to skip and instead of having a meal at the institution, I'd go to the cafe, have a cup of coffee and put a coin in the slot and play whatever my favorite song was. I realised that what I truly liked about rock'n'roll is the bass line on the keyboard, the driving force. I recognized that the artists I was hearing were figures like Fats, Jerry Lee, Little Richard, and I saw the left hand side, the rhythmic piano, was the core of rock'n'roll ... There were no basses in Birmingham at the time. When the instrument finally arrived to the area, it appeared in a store called the shop. Every weekend, all the aspiring players would go there and practice their instruments and pick up something different from others. And one day, I went there and I spotted 'American-made bass guitar' in the window. So I went back and said to my dad, could you help me purchase this bass? And we went back to the store, I acquired it, and it's been with me ever since."
By 1972, the Moodies were genuinely massive, and influenced by their propensity for vague but somewhat profound-sounding lyrics, listeners took to believing they possessed greater wisdom than they actually did, a situation that inspired what became Lodge's defining composition for the Moodies, "I'm Just a Singer (In a Rock and Roll Band)." The song, which peaked at number twelve in the US as a release, saw Lodge rejecting any kind of knowledge: "And if you want the shift to affect you / And you're the only additional person to understand, don't tell me / I'm just a singer in a rock 'n' roll band."
The 1973 concert series to support "the album Seventh Sojourn" saw the Moody Blues living a way of life more commonly associated with other rock giants. As Lodge recalled in the liner notes for a new edition of the album: "We had our own jet aircraft which was fitted with a sitting room and a hearth. There were a couple of sleeping quarters, some twenty separate televisions, audio systems everywhere, and we had our dedicated butler and our band name displayed on the exterior of the plane. I had a very empty sensation realizing that matters had become this over-the-top."
The following period, the group went on break for several years. It was likely a good job, because as a critic wrote in ZigZag in the mid-70s, just as the punk movement was emerging, "They make albums which sell to affluent fashionable pairs living in the suburban areas who know and care as much about rock music as a fictional character."
When they returned in the late 70s, with the "Octave" album, it didn't quite resemble the Clash, but the album's first track, Lodge's "Steppin' in a Slide Zone," showed that the Moody Blues could adapt to changing times without sacrificing their core identity – the multitracked singing and distinctive instrumentation were remained in place, but "the song" had an aridity that still sounds very of that era, precise and tight and tense. Just in case listeners was put off, Lodge's "Survival" from that very album had orchestras to complement the synths, and the softness that was one of the band's notable qualities.
However although they were the remarkable survivors and major successes of psychedelia's's golden age – perhaps only Paul McCartney had more acclaim for longer – the Moody Blues never held a prominent place in culture. But they did occupy their unique space, and that was more than adequate for the multitudes of people who never stopped loving them.
And Lodge did not took music lightly. He always saw in it the possibility for something beyond mere amusement. In that recent interview, he was questioned what "psychedelic" meant to him, and answered perfectly: "I hope your imagination will delve into the music and lead you wherever the music guides you. It's not a case of joining in, it's paying attention. It can be a single tone and that transports you somewhere. And I believe if you can conjure up experiences and stories in your thoughts where the melody leads you, to me that's psychedelic. You have to listen to things, not just hear them."